Martin Partington: Spotlight on the Justice System

Keeping the English Legal System under review

Legal Aid, Sentencing and punishment of offenders Bill 2011

with one comment

The Legal Aid, Sentencing and punishment of offenders Bill 2011 is the big one, certainly so far as the legal system is concerned. It is a complex measure, attempting to achieve three quite distinct policy objectives. Underpinning much of it is the Government’s desire to cut public expenditure.

This is seen most clearly in Part 1 which deals with legal aid. The long awaited abolition of the Legal Services Commission is contained in the Bill, together with provision of the appointment of a Director of Legal Aid who will head up a new agency within the Ministry of Justice. In practical terms, it is the changes (i.e. cuts) to civil legal aid that are likely to have the most significant impact on the ground. The Bill gives legislative effect to the Government’s proposals to make fundamental changes to legal aid – which will take a lot of issues currently in scope of the legal aid scheme out of the scope of legal aid, will increase the charges paid by members of the public for getting legal aid assistance and reduce the sums paid to lawyers who provide legal aid services.

Arguments that have been made by many – not just lawyers – about the impact these changes will have on access to justice have been met by the Government’s counter argument that the UK spends too much on legal aid – far more than most other countries. It has to be said, however, that by comparison with the proposals for reform of sentencing (see below) these changes have not actually received much attention in the mass media.

Details of the proposals for change can be found at

Part 2 of the Bill deals with recommendations of Lord Justice Jackson about making changes to the current system of ‘no-win-no-fee’ Conditional Fee Agreement cases, to limit the amounts that lawyers can charge by way of success fees.

The Government argues: [CFAs] have played an important role in extending access to justice but they also enable claims to be pursued with no real risk to claimants and the threat of excessive costs to defendants. It cannot be right that, regardless of the extreme weakness of a claim, the sensible thing for the defendant to do is to settle, and get out before the legal costs start running up. This is precisely what has happened and it is one of the worst instances of this country’s compensation culture…

[T]he Government believes that the right way forward is to abolish the recoverability of CFA success fees and ATE insurance premiums.

The Bill provides for these changes: for more detail see also

The final part of the Bill deals with proposals for reforming sentencing. These issues were debated heavily in the press, with the Justice Secretary facing a lot of criticism that he was being ‘soft on crime’ – wanting to keep people out of prison to save money. The quite respectable argument – which at the least demands a careful hearing – that more might be done to turn people away from crime if they were not in prison was a subtlety that got lost in much of the mass media.

In the light of the decision not to proceed with the idea for giving those pleading guilty to charges a higher discount from their sentence than they can currently get, the Bill’s proposals are more modest than were originally envisaged by the Government when it published its Consultation Paper on the reform of Sentencing in November 2010.

The Bill is currently in the Committee stage, which will end in mid-October 2011. I estimate that the Bill will pass into law early in 2012.

Details on all three components of the Bill will be considered further here and in the book in due course.


Written by lwtmp

July 28, 2011 at 8:05 am

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Hi thanks for information ,actually I’m looking for this information I’m facing some problem related to this matter.

    No Win No fee

    July 28, 2011 at 3:14 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: